Yes, it’s important to enforce all classroom rules. Your consistency is key to your classroom management success.
However, there is one rule you should absolutely positively never let slide.
Because it opens the door to every other type of misbehavior. Furthermore, it’s a rule teachers often fail to enforce.
So what is it?
Raise your hand before speaking or leaving your seat.
It’s that first part—Raise your hand before speaking—that can cause the lion’s share of problems.
Although the behavior seems so innocent and is often accidental, if isn’t enforced 100 percent of the time, it will slowly, almost imperceptibly, causes a dominoing of misbehavior.
The reason is because it so publicly announces your inconsistency. A student calls out and every other student in the class hears it, making your lack of follow through a statement everyone will understand.
The rule is critical because . . .
- It’s fair to everyone.
- It includes everyone.
- It encourages everyone to participate.
- It offers students time to think before you call on them.
- It avoids more than one student speaking at the same time.
- It protects the speaker from interruption.
- It protects you and your lesson from interruption.
- It’s universally polite.
When you fail to enforce a consequence for calling out, you’re sending the message that hand-raising isn’t important and therefore the list above isn’t important either.
But it’s that last bullet point that does the most damage.
Calling out is rude. Period. And once you allow it, once you leave the sacredness of classroom politeness behind, more rude behavior will follow. Every single time.
Before you know it, you have a culture of discourtesy, incivility, and coarseness. Students will tread on the rights of others without a second thought.
Teachers often complain about how mean their students are to each other. But the source can often be traced back to inconsistency.
The purpose of having class rules is to protect students from bullying, disruption, interruption, and disrespect so they can learn in peace. No rule represents this better than Raise your hand because it’s so clearly and obviously required to maintain decorum.
The moment you look the other way or choose not to enforce, everyone in your class will know that it’s unimportant to you. No one is there to protect them or their right to fairly express their thoughts, ideas, and opinions.
It’s everyone for themselves.
The bullies and boors will rise up.
The rest will grow timid and quiet.
PS – Check out this week’s YouTube videos:
1. You’re Making Your Students Misbehave Without Realizing It
2. Why You Must Give Students More Freedom
3. Why Students Misbehave When They Finish Their Work
Also, if you haven’t done so already, join us. It’s free! Click here and begin receiving classroom management articles like this one in your email box every week.

Yes. It doesn’t matter if they are answering a question the teacher raised, or adding a thoughtful comment on what the teacher just said. Hands must be raised. Order must be kept so all can learn.
If we’re consistently enforcing the rule that students must raise their hands before speaking, what should we do when a student calls out anyway? Do we simply remind them, or should there be a consequence if it continues?
I agree with this… However, I add CLARITY to this rule in my wording: Raise your hand before speaking/leaving your seat and WAIT to be called on by the teacher/for teacher permission to do so. The way it is stated, taken word for word, some students will raise their hand and SIMULTANEOUSLY start speaking, test the limits of this rule, thinking they now have permission to do so (big no, no!!! THIS behavior warrants a warning in my book).
You’re right. That is a necessary addition to the classroom rule.
Suppose teachers word it like the following?
“Raise your hand and be recognized by the teacher before speaking or leaving your seat.”
Organizations follow parliamentary procedure (“Robert’s Rules of Order”) to transact business effectively. When children follow this universal rule, they take a necessary step in learning how to conduct themselves as responsible adults and effective citizens.
Thank you for this great reminder!
Hi Michael, I appreciate this reminder. I’d like to submit an idea for a future article: How do you set up a specials or substitute teacher for success? Thanks in advance!
It’s so hard to be consistent. I have small groups, and often it seems unnecessary to require hand-raising.
For the FIRST TIME EVERRR!!! and I mean EVER! — I have to politely, yet strongly, disagree with this. Perhaps for my age range (I’ve taught 7th-11th grades, all capabilities) I do not believe this is a requirement.
I SUBSCRIBE to 99.99% of these practices; today, after reading this one, I have met the .01%. Not hand raising is a part of my “shtick” — we’ve all got one. Love to tell you about it sometime. My class communities should be duplicated 😉